Prompts winter weather advisories as cold air moves in Friday night

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

A new fight is brewing over Prince, his estate and music you haven't heard before.


Prince's estate is suing a California sound engineer who is offering a multi-song selection of unreleased music from the late pop icon. The two sides faced off in an 80-minute federal court hearing Wednesday afternoon before U.S. District Court Judge Wilhelmina Wright in St. Paul.

Prince is gone, but his business empire lives on

His life and music


Lora Friedemann, the attorney for Prince's estate, told the judge that 

 was only working for Prince and didn't have any rights to performances recorded at Paisley Park in 2006. 


"Anything he may have done to modify or use them for his own purpose, that all belongs to the estate," Friedemann said. Briefs filed with the case argue that rights to Prince's unreleased music have already been assigned to Universal Music Group.

The estate asked Wright to issue an injunction that would bar Boxill or the Rogue Music Alliance record company from releasing 

 they started promoting Tuesday night — even releasing a title tune, "Deliverance," online. More was to follow on Friday, the anniversary of Prince's death, at 57, due to an accidental fentanyl overdose at his home at Paisley Park.

"The toothpaste is out of the tube, and we're not at all happy about that," Friedemann told the judge. She implored Wright to stop any more releases. "The music is unique. We can't release something else ... It's absolutely taken that opportunity away from us in a way that we will never be able to quantify."
 


Attorney Tony Zeuli, arguing for Boxill, said that in fact it could be quantified — that the two sides had been talking about the music and what to do with it as long as eight months ago, but disagreed on money. He suggested that the estate was dragging its feet, to Boxill's detriment.

He made several other arguments as well. "Mr. Boxill is not just a sound engineer," Zeuli told the judge. "He's a co-author." Zeuli told the judge Boxill was "responsible for the guitar tone, the bass tone and drum tone," and "composed, recorded and produced the backup vocals." 

Zeuli also told the judge that Boxill produces and releases his own music.

Boxill was not in court. His attorney said he was in Trinidad, following the death of his father there.

Zeuli countered the estate's argument that Boxill was bound by a non-disclosure agreement to turn over any results of his work at Paisley Park and surrender any rights. 

Zeuli pointed out that Boxill did sign a confidentiality agreement, but that neither Prince nor anyone else from Paisley Park did so. He also contended that the agreement only applied to work Boxill did in 2004 for Prince, not a more collaborative arrangement they'd struck — but apparently did not document — in 2006.

"It's not an agreement with regard to musical works," Zeuli argued. "It looks to be an agreement to protect the privacy of Prince."

That music, for now, remains under wraps. The original title track was gone from iTunes and Apple music by the time the federal hearing ended in St. Paul. It isn't clear if the rest will be released on Friday, as the Rogue Music Alliance had promised.

Judge Wright questioned both attorneys closely during the hearing about copyright law, the limits of the confidentiality agreement Boxill signed and the nature of intellectual property rights. She even asked if an injunction blocking the release of the music might not actually make the EP valuable because of the controversy and scarcity surrounding the music — part of a potential trove of work that Prince left behind, but never made public during his lifetime.

Wright adjourned the hearing without giving an indication of when she might rule.

Arts and Culture

Shows

Morning Edition

Morning Edition: Music

Tim Nelson

Author

Prince's estate is suing a California sound engineer who is offering a multi-song selection of unreleased music from the late pop icon. The two sides faced off in an 80-minute federal court hearing Wednesday afternoon before U.S. District Court Judge Wilhelmina Wright in St. Paul.

Today's Morning Edition music is based on a new legal fight brewing over some previously unreleased Prince tracks. Former Paisley Park sound engineer George Ian Boxill announced yesterday that Rogue Media Alliance will be releasing a six-song Prince EP on Friday. But Prince's estate is joining with Paisley Park Enterprises to sue Boxill, saying he does not have the rights to release the music.  In a news release, Boxhill says that the songs were recorded between 2006 and 2008 and that he has spent the last year "completing the compositions and arrangements, finishing the production and mixing the songs." The EP is called "Deliverance" and the title track is currently available on iTunes.

Engineer, Prince's estate face off in court over unreleased music

Go Deeper.

Like this?