Prompts winter weather advisories as cold air moves in Friday night

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

Oregon child welfare officials knew the family in an SUV that plunged off a California cliff had faced a child abuse investigation in another state when it looked into allegations in 2013, according to documents released Monday.

Oregon Child Protective Services obtained records from Minnesota prior to investigating Jennifer and Sarah Hart in July 2013, 

. But the agency closed the case with investigators concluding that they were "unable to determine" whether there was abuse in the home, despite some indications of abuse or neglect.

Records obtained by the TV station show the agency found "some indications of child abuse or neglect" but insufficient information to conclude that it occurred.

California authorities have determined that Jennifer Hart 

drove her large family off a Northern California cliff

 last month and they suspect the crash was intentional. They are still trying to determine a motive.

Toxicology results showed Jennifer Hart's wife and several children had large amounts of a drug in their systems that can cause drowsiness.

The crash happened just days after authorities in Washington state — where the family moved last year from Oregon — opened an investigation following allegations the children were being neglected.


A neighbor of the Harts in Woodland, Washington, had filed a complaint with the state, saying the children were apparently being deprived of food as punishment. No one answered when social workers checking on the report knocked on the family's door March 23, days before their SUV was found off a cliff in Mendocino County north of San Francisco.

Child abuse allegations in Minnesota

Long before the crash, Sarah Hart pleaded guilty in 2011 to a domestic assault charge in Douglas County, Minn., over what she said was a spanking given to one of her children.

In that case, the child reported that her mother "had hit her and .. had put her in the bathtub and turned on the cold water and hit her," according to the Alexandria police report. The child said she was punished for picking up a penny and putting it into her pocket.

The child also told authorities that sometimes she was denied food.

The perplexing thing about the report is that the child said it was Jennifer Hart who hit her and not Sarah. However, Sarah Hart admitted to striking the child when interview by a detective, according to the police report.

"Sarah stated she was upset at (the child) for lying. She stated she went to (give her) a bath and in doing so, had bent her over the tub and gave her some swats to her backside ... By Sarah's own admission, she stated that the spanking got out of control and was not proper and was 'too much,'" the police report said.

Alexandra Argyropoulos previously told The Associated Press that she contacted Oregon child welfare officials in 2013. The former Hart family friend said she "witnessed what I felt to be controlling emotional abuse and cruel punishment" toward the six children.

Oregon child-welfare officials previously declined to disclose any information about the family, citing privacy laws. But records obtained by the TV station show state child-welfare investigators first tried to contact the family on July 19, 2013.

They didn't observe anyone at home and left a card asking the family to contact a caseworker. Three days later, Sarah Hart called the caseworker, saying the family was soon going out of town. She denied that the children were undernourished, KOIN-TV reported.

Documents show that two people whom CPS investigators contacted expressed concern that the Harts limited food for the six children and noted excessive discipline, including having the children lay on the ground in a dark room for between four and seven hours, KOIN-TV reported.

Growth charts provided to investigators showed all but one of the children were below the chart for height and weight though the doctor said there were no concerns for any of the children despite their size.

The bodies of the women and four children have been recovered. Two other Hart children remain missing and the FBI has placed them on its missing persons list. Nonetheless, investigators said they have no evidence indicating the two remaining children are still alive and officials continue to search the ocean and nearby beaches.

MPR News reporter Catharine Richert contributed to this report.

Crime, Law and Justice

NewsPartners

The Associated Press

Author

Oregon child welfare officials knew the family in an SUV that plunged off a California cliff had faced a child abuse investigation in another state when it looked into allegations in 2013.

Oregon knew of abuse case against family that went off cliff

Go Deeper.

Like this?