Wintry mix spreads across Minnesota

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

As of Tuesday afternoon, international rescue crews are still searching the North Atlantic for a submersible vessel that was taking five people to view the wreckage from the Titanic. 

Authorities estimate there's only enough oxygen in the sub for those onboard to survive less than two days. 

When and where did the vessel go missing? 

, lost communication with its control center on Sunday morning, roughly 1 hour and 45 minutes into its scheduled dive, 

Titan had been deployed by a Canadian expedition ship, the Polar Prince, about 

 of St. John's in Newfoundland, not far from the site of the iconic shipwreck. 

The missing vessel is owned by OceanGate, a company based in Washington state that offers underwater voyages to explore the remains of the Titanic from the seafloor. 

OceanGate is a major chronicler of the ship's decay and shared the 

first-ever full-size digital scan of the wreck site

OceanGate is also a pioneer in the deep sea tourism economy. For $250,000 a person, the company takes adventurers on a deep sea tour lasting eight days and stretching hundreds of miles.  

From St. John's in Newfoundland, Canada, explorers travel 380 miles offshore and 2.4 miles below the surface. 

If successful, they can catch a glimpse of what's left of the 1912 iceberg-crash disaster, which took the lives of all but 700 of the Titanic's 2,200 passengers and crew. Today, the ship is 

slowly succumbing to a metal-eating bacteria

, which may cause it to fully disintegrate in a matter of decades. 

, who joined OceanGate to glimpse the deteriorating wreck in 2022, said the trip is less tourism than it is true exploration — and the people who dare to try it are made well aware of the risks. 

"You sign a massive waiver that lists one way after another that you could die on the trip," he told the BBC in an interview Tuesday. "They mention death three times on page one. So it's never far from your mind. As I was getting on to the sub, that was my thought: That this could be the end."

The Titanic-touring vessel contained one pilot and four paid passengers called "mission specialists," according to the U.S. Coast Guard. "Mission specialists" take turns operating sonar equipment and performing the tasks necessary to complete a dive. 

Among those paid passengers was British businessman Hamish Harding, according to 

, a company where Harding works as chairman. 

Harding holds three Guinness World Records, including 

 (4 hours, 15 minutes) at a full ocean depth (2.88 miles) by a crewed vessel. He has also trekked to the South Pole, 

in less than 48 hours and visited space in 

Shahzada Dawood and his son Suleman, two members of a prominent Pakistani family known for investing, were also on board the vessel, according to a statement shared 

with outlets such as The Associated Press

A fourth person on board is Paul-Henri Nargeolet, a French expert on the Titanic, his agent has confirmed to several outlets, 

, the U.S. company that owns the salvage rights to the Titanic site. The 

reports that Nargeolet has completed over 35 dives to the wreckage, including a previous Titan expedition.  

Titan's pilot and the fifth person has been identified as OceanGate CEO Stockton Rush. 

It's still unclear why the sub lost communication with its control crew on the expedition ship. 

OceanGate said it would rely on the satellite-based internet company Starlink

 for the communications necessary for carrying out the expedition. A text-message-based system relying on underwater acoustic positioning normally allows the Titan to communicate with the control ship, 

according to an Australian researcher writing for 

OceanGate says its vessels are "equipped with some basic emergency medical supplies and 96 hours of life support," according to 

And for good reason: This is not the first time an OceanGate submersible has gotten lost, according to David Pogue, a correspondent for 

Pogue, who traveled on an OceanGate expedition to see the Titanic last summer, recalled that the control room was unable to help the submersible locate the wrecked liner for roughly three hours due to technical difficulties.

"The difference this year is that it seems like they lost contact with the ship," Pogue told NPR. "They can't even reach the sub and that's really scary."

He added that factors like bad weather and mechanical issues mean the submersible vessels rarely make it to the Titanic, despite the expensive price tag. This season has seen zero successful dives, Pogue said. 

 on OceanGate show him reading from the "mission specialist" waiver, which points out that Titan has not been approved or certified "by any regulatory body."

"I couldn't help noticing how many pieces of this sub seem improvised," Pogue adds. 

A single plastic bottle and some Ziploc bags stand in for a toilet. An Xbox game controller and an elevator-esque up/down button serve as the vessel's primary controls. The interior lighting is from Camping World, notes OceanGate founder Stockton Rush.   

In whole, the space inside is about the size of a minivan, not tall enough for someone to fully stand. 

, Pogue said there are seven different ballast mechanisms that can help the Titan rise from great depths. 

"Some of these work even if the power is out or even if everyone on board is passed out," Pogue said. 

The fact that rescue crews haven't spotted the vessel on the ocean's surface might mean that the Titan is snagged or its 5-foot-thick carbon fiber hull was penetrated, Pogue said. 

Either situation could be catastrophic for the people on board. 

What's the latest on the search efforts? 

As of Tuesday at 1 p.m. ET, the Titan had about 40 hours of oxygen left, said Capt. Jamie Frederick, a response coordinator for the U.S. Coast Guard overseeing the search. 

A unified command including the U.S. Coast Guard, the U.S. Navy, the Canadian Coast Guard and OceanGate are working together to steer the search efforts, but so far, has come up unsuccessful, Frederick said during a press conference.

"We wouldn't be searching and putting all effort out there" if the sub wasn't recoverable, Frederick said, adding that the crews contain the "nation's best experts." 

Several Canadian Coast Guard vessels were en route to the scene, as were several additional private vessels. 

The teams in place are continuing to use aircraft to scan the ocean, an effort that may get easier on Tuesday as Monday's heavy fog was lifting, said a Coast Guard spokesperson. 

Sonar devices are also being employed to detect possible underwater sounds coming from the submersible. Crews have covered 7,600 square miles — an area bigger than the state of Connecticut. 

The teams also expanded their underwater search capability on Tuesday by adding a remotely operated vehicle in order to reach lower depths. That search is ongoing. 

But even if the crews can locate the vessel at a low depth, hauling it up to the surface is another task. The Titan could be at a depth of over 13,000 feet and a distance of over 900 miles offshore. Frederick said the search and rescue crews did not yet have salvage equipment in place. 

David Marquet, a retired U.S. Navy submarine captain, told 

 that the odds of survival are "about 1 percent." 

A former OceanGate executive voiced safety concerns years ago 

A fired OceanGate employee urged for additional testing on the hull of the Titan years earlier, according to a 2018 lawsuit. 

Former director of marine operations David Lochridge sent a report he authored in January 2018, which voiced concerns that the hull used carbon fiber and not a metallic composition. The Titan was being designed to travel 4,000 meters below the surface, which had never been done by an OceanGate vessel with a hull made of carbon fiber, Lochridge stated in court documents. 

Furthermore, Lochridge said vessel's viewport, which allows passengers to look outside, was only certified by the manufacturer to withstand pressures at 1,300 meters below the surface. That was

due to OceanGate's design of the vessel, which did not meet federal standards, according to the complaint. 

Lochridge said he encouraged a nondestructive scan of the hull to check for any defects, rather than solely relying on acoustic monitoring. According to Lochridge, acoustic monitoring only detects a problem in the hull right before it fails. 

Lochridge said his concerns were ignored and he was told equipment did not exist for the type of test he was asking for. 

"The paying passengers would not be aware, and would not be informed, of this experimental design, the lack of non-destructive testing of the hull, or that hazardous flammable materials were being used within the submersible," court documents state. 

In its lawsuit against Lochridge, OceanGate said they did not hire him to do engineering work. However, Lochridge says he made the report at the request of CEO Stockton Rush because the plans for the Titan were being passed from the engineering team to his operations department.

Lochridge, who has experience as a submersible pilot and diver, was hired by OceanGate in May 2015 as an independent contractor and later became an employee, according to documents. 

OceanGate sued Lochridge for fraud, breach of contract, misappropriation of trade secrets and nearly $24,000, claiming that he repeatedly violated the nondisclosure agreement he signed by talking to at least two people about plans for the Titan. 

The agreement stated he would not disparage the company and would "hold [OceanGate's] confidential information in strict confidence, and not disclose or use it except as authorized by [OceanGate] and for [OceanGate's] benefit." 

Lochridge denied violating the NDA, saying it was not properly executed and that his report was not critical of the company. He countersued for wrongful termination, though the parties ultimately reached a settlement.

International

Emily Olson

Author

Ayana Archie

The Titan, a minivan-size submersible, was carrying five people to the Titanic's watery grave when it lost contact. The vessel has enough oxygen to keep its passengers alive for about 40 more hours.

Here's the latest on the missing Titanic sub and the race to rescue those inside

Go Deeper.

Like this?

News you can use in your inbox