Cooler but still well above normal this week

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

Elon Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency have an ambitious goal of cutting $1 trillion in federal spending by the end of the fiscal year in September. 

But DOGE’s moves so far to cancel contracts, end leases and push federal agencies to reduce their workforces barely make a dent in the government’s overall balance sheet — even if you take DOGE’s savings claims at face value.

, those early DOGE savings claims have been inaccurate and drastically overstated.

In Congress, where decisions about trillions of dollars in spending are debated and authorized in appropriations bills, House Republicans have 

 that would include $4.5 trillion in tax cuts and a goal of $2 trillion in spending cuts. There are several more steps until legislation like that could get final approval.

It’s through congressional action, not DOGE, where any changes to spending and revenue collection would happen at a meaningful scale, said Jessica Riedl of the center-right Manhattan Institute.

“Think of Congress and its budget as the debt-ridden dad on the way to buy a $250,000 Ferrari on the credit card, and DOGE is the $2-off gas card he used along the way,” Riedl said. “It's great that he saved $2 on gas, but I think his wife may be more concerned about the $250,000 car.”

DOGE’s alleged savings are a drop in the budget bucket

For every dollar that the federal government has spent so far since the start of this fiscal year in October 2024, DOGE — which began operating in mid-January — has claimed to save the equivalent of about four pennies.

From Oct. 1, 2024, through Jan. 31, 2025, the federal government collected 

 from a combination of things like lease terminations, contract cancellations and firing federal workers.

 what the Department of Homeland Security reported spending during the first quarter of this fiscal year and slightly less than what the Department of Veterans Affairs has spent on benefits and health care for millions of veterans. It’s also a third of what the government has paid in interest on the 

 national debt during the first four months of the fiscal year.

DOGE’s claim of $105 billion saved in six weeks can’t be proved, however, and the “wall of receipts” that accounts for a fraction of that number is full of inaccurate data that has been 

. Government contracting experts also say DOGE’s website inflates claims of “savings” by including misleading math about contract cancellations.

The White House did not respond to NPR's questions about how DOGE calculates its savings totals or how the DOGE effort could work with Congress on federal spending.

But even DOGE'S unverifiable $105 billion number is less than half the pace of what Musk himself says is needed to meet its savings goal. 

“It requires saving $4 billion per day every day from now through the end of September,” Musk said during President Trump’s 

 last week. “But we can do it, and we will do it.”

DOGE has so far focused on things like contracting and employee head count, which account for a small slice of the government spending pie.

It recalls a similar move for Musk, who, after he bought Twitter in 2022, got rid of most of the staff. But unlike private industry, where employee salaries and benefits are the top expense, in the federal government personnel costs make up just about 4 percent of spending.

What’s the biggest part of the federal budget?

, about 64 percent of the government’s spending has been on Social Security, Medicare, health programs, income security and veterans’ benefits and services.

Add in another 14 percent for national defense and 13 percent for interest on the debt, and it’s clear what the biggest savings targets are.

Riedl, of the Manhattan Institute, says any reduction in the government wasting taxpayer dollars is a good thing, no matter the dollar amount.

But as someone who has spent a quarter-century studying ways to cut extraneous spending, Riedl reiterates that Congress is the only place to find real savings, and even then it requires tough choices.

“DOGE has created this false perception that the entire budget deficit can be eliminated by going after waste, fraud and abuse and without making the difficult decisions elsewhere in the budget,” Riedl said. “And this exaggeration is making it even harder to do the real hard things that are going to be needed to fix the deficit beyond waste.”

Politics and Government News

Homepage

Stephen Fowler

Author

Even if you take DOGE’s savings claims so far at face value, its moves to cancel contracts, end leases and push federal agencies to reduce head count barely dent the government’s balance sheet.

DOGE wants to cut $1 trillion this year. But it’s not looking at big spending drivers

Go Deeper.

Like this?

News you can use in your inbox