Spring Lake Park Mayor decision could be taken to court

Go Deeper.
Create an account or log in to save stories.
Like this?
Thanks for liking this story! We have added it to a list of your favorite stories.
A tie, a drawing of lots, a recount, and then a final decision by a canvassing board not to count a single contested vote led to Spring Lake Park electing a newcomer as mayor over the city’s incumbent.
But this likely won’t be the end of this saga as current Mayor Robert Nelson has seven days to contest this decision in Anoka County District Court.
Nelson originally tied with challenger Halyn Roth in the November elections. Nelson won a drawing of lots that determines a tied city race per state statute.
Roth quickly called for a recount.
Turn Up Your Support
MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all.
City Administrator Daniel Buchholtz explained that a recount by hand can decide a race if ballots were missed by the voting machine due to voter error. For example, a vote could go uncounted if a voter crossed out one oval and filled in another. During a recount, election workers look at ballots like this and determine if there was clear voter intent.
During the hours-long recount held Tuesday, both Roth and Nelson pulled out multiple ballots for additional review. They ultimately agreed on the ultimate determination of intent by ballot counters for all of these ballots but one.
Roth submitted a challenge to one ballot originally determined to be intended for Nelson. A challenge in a recount goes to a city’s canvassing board, which for Spring Lake Park is the city council.
Spring Lake Park shared with MPR News a PDF of the contested ballot that tipped the scales in this race. There is a clear pen mark in the oval for Robert Nelson. A small dot can be seen in Halyn Roth’s oval.
“My recommendation to the canvassing board was to overrule the challenge because – in my judgment based on my understanding of the law and my 25 years of experience in the election system in Minnesota – I believed you could determine voter intent,” Buchholtz said.
The board went against this recommendation and voted 3 to 1 to sustain Roth’s challenge, with the mayor abstaining and Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff voting against the motion. Roth was declared the winner of the race by one vote.
Nelson now has a seven-day window where he can file a contest to the election result in Anoka County District Court. If he does this, a hearing will be held, and a judge could overturn the canvassing board’s decision, which would mean Nelson would retain his mayoral seat.
Nelson has not responded to requests for comment.
But council member Ken Wendling is anticipating a filing. The council member, since 2014, said the mayor walked out of council chambers after the canvassing board meeting “saying, ‘See you in court.’”
Wendling was one of the council members who voted to sustain Roth’s contest. He said he and the other two council members who voted to sustain the challenge looked at both sides of the ballot and noted that the marking filling the mayor’s oval was less distinct than the markings in ovals for other races.
“But now it’s going to court so we will see,” Wendling said.
Roth issued a statement after the decision in which he said he is focusing on preparing to transition into the mayoral role. He also acknowledged Nelson’s right to pursue legal action following the decision and wrote: “Out of respect for the integrity of the legal and electoral processes, I will not be making any further statements on this matter at this time.”
