Education News

St. Paul Public Schools under federal investigation for gender inclusion policy

A high school and parking lot
Johnson Senior High School in St. Paul.
St. Paul Public Schools

The U.S. Department of Education is investigating St. Paul Public Schools over its gender inclusion policies.

The agency alleges the district’s policy is concealing information about a child’s gender identity from parents. It points to the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment, which requires schools to get parental consent before asking students to fill out forms that reveal private information, as well as the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, which requires schools to allow parents to inspect their child’s education records.

“The law is clear: schools do not decide what information is shared with parents, the law does,” writes Frank Miller, director of the Student Privacy Policy Office.

A district spokesperson said its gender inclusion policy does not violate any laws.

The district's "Name/Gender/Pronoun Change Request Form" does require a parent’s signature for a student under age 18. Students themselves also don’t have to fill out a form to request that staff address them by their preferred name or pronouns.

“We are committed to supporting and maintaining respectful and inclusive learning environments that foster a sense of belonging and respect students' gender identity and gender expression,” a district spokesperson said in a statement.

The Department of Education also pointed to a “Gender Support Plan” policy that it alleges also violated law, but the district says that policy doesn’t exist. The agency hyperlinked to the district’s change request form when referring to the policy.

Four other school districts across the country are also under investigation including Eau Claire Area School District in Wisconsin.

Overall, the Trump administration has opened dozens of investigations into schools that make accommodations for transgender and LGBTQ+ students.