The recount that didn't count

Ballot counters
Dick Jarvis and Rosalie Forkner, both of Northfield, helped recount ballots from a Northfield city council race. Before the recount was complete, the loser conceded the race.
MPR Photo/Tim Nelson

A recount in Rice County got underway Monday morning in Faribault. At stake was a city council seat in the city of Northfield.

The incumbent, Kris Voss, was running for re-election and a former city council member, Dana Graham, was running to get back on the council.

Watching ballots
Northfield City Clerk Deb Little, left, talked about a disputed ballot with city council member Kris Vohs, center and challenger Dana Graham, right. The two were separated by only 14 votes from among about 7,500 votes. After sorting through the ballots for most of Monday morning, Graham conceded the race to Vohs.
MPR Photo/Tim Nelson

The two finished just 14 votes apart on election night. Voss had the lead with 3,726 votes.

So the two candidates were on hand for the recount.

Create a More Connected Minnesota

MPR News is your trusted resource for the news you need. With your support, MPR News brings accessible, courageous journalism and authentic conversation to everyone - free of paywalls and barriers. Your gift makes a difference.

It was a very close race, about one tenth of one percent of the vote. But after they finished working their way through four of the city's nine precincts, Graham -- who'd lost -- conceded.

Like most recounts, there wasn't a big shift in the outcome. In fact, only one vote changed from the ballots that were recounted.

The process was very deliberate, with three sets of judges who would sort all the ballots into piles for each of the two candidates -- and another pile for blank votes -- and then go back and count them.

Pile of ballots
Election judges Earl Forkner, left, and Alex Beeby, right, sorted through the ballots cast for the Northfield City Council race. A 14-vote gap between two contenders prompted a recount Monday, although candidate Dana Graham conceded before the recount was complete.
MPR Photo/Tim Nelson

When the count didn't match the election night total, the officials would go back and count them again, and again and again until they got a consistent result.

It's extremely meticulous and extremely time consuming process.

Remember, there are about 3 million votes to count in Minnesota's Senate race so you can see the task elections officials are going to have at hand when they start a recount.

Alex Beeby, from Northfield serves as a head judge on Election Day. He's very familiar with the whole process and spent about three hours this morning, leafing through the ballots.

There were a couple that were mismarked, and a couple piles that had to be recounted over and over. But he's pretty sanguine about the whole thing.

Hand counting ballots
Election judge Alex Beeby counted out ballots by hand in the recount of the Northfield City Council election. Council member Kris Vohs and challenger Dana Graham were separated by just 14 votes from among more than 7,400 cast. Graham conceded after a recount of just two precincts showed no major shift in the vote.
MPR Photo/Tim Nelson

"It's good to see that the process we use on election night runs through," said Beeby. "The machines we have are extremely accurate and we have a really good process. Its good to know things work out that way." That was after just three hours of counting, remember, and the counting in the U.S. Senate election could go on for days, even weeks.

The Secretary of State put out a list this afternoon that designates 107 different locations where they could be counting ballots after the State Canvassing Board meets on Tuesday.