Western, central and northern Minnesota under windy, dry weather conditions 

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

A controversial rule backed by U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, and meant to reroute millions of dollars in coronavirus aid to K-12 private school students, has been shut down, at least temporarily. 

 Wednesday that the rule is no longer in effect, after a federal judge determined that the department had not only "acted beyond its authority" but misinterpreted the will of Congress. 

At the center of this months-long fight between DeVos and public school advocates is the CARES Act, passed in March. The law set aside 

 in federal aid to help schools cover their budget-crushing pandemic costs. 

Plaintiffs in the lawsuit, led by the NAACP, argued that the money was meant to be distributed to public school districts based on how many low-income students they serve. For private schools, lawmakers required districts to set aside a small portion of that money to pay for "equitable services" such as tutoring or transportation, though only for those schools' low-income students.

DeVos and her Education Department read the law differently, arguing throughout the summer that private schools should receive help based on how many students they serve 

, rather than just their share of low-income students. This could mean, in places with large private school populations, districts serving low-income students could be required to spend relief money on their more affluent, private school neighbors.

 vacating the rule, Judge Dabney Friedrich, of the U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., wrote, "it is difficult to imagine how Congress could have been clearer" about its intention that these equitable services be reserved for low-income students only. "The Department's arguments to the contrary do not change this straightforward conclusion."

 by the Learning Policy Institute, the department's reading of the CARES Act would have increased private schools' share of CARES Act dollars from $127 million to $1.5 billion. The department first issued its controversial interpretation of the law in late-April, 

. While that guidance was nonbinding, the interim final rule 

"The CARES Act is a special, pandemic-related appropriation to benefit all American students, teachers, and families impacted by coronavirus," DeVos 

. "There is nothing in the law Congress passed that would allow districts to discriminate against children and teachers based on private school attendance and employment."

, Daniel A. Domenech, executive director of the School Superintendents Association (AASA), called the rule "an opportunistic money grab, using the pandemic environment to advance the privatization agenda."

In announcing the rule, the Education Department 

 that "most private schools serving low- and middle-income communities are under great financial strain due to COVID-19" and that "more than 100 private schools have already announced they will not be able to reopen following the pandemic, and hundreds more are facing a similar fate."

Public school advocates argue this fight over how federal aid dollars should be used has forced districts to delay spending, even as their COVID-related costs mount. In an 

, Rep. Bobby Scott, the Democratic chairman of the House education committee, wrote, "I once again implore the Department to abandon its unlawful 

 rule and finally provide schools the clarity and resources they need to cope with this unprecedented crisis."

As a result of the court's decision, the rule is no longer in effect, but the Education Department tells NPR that it has not officially rescinded the rule and could still decide to appeal. 

Education News

Politics and Government News

Cory Turner

Author

A federal judge says U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos overstepped in trying to send more CARES Act money to help students at private schools.

DeVos loses latest fight over rerouting aid to private school students

Go Deeper.

Like this?

News you can use in your inbox