School, college and other closings for Monday

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

Facebook has extended former President Donald Trump's suspension for two years and says it will only reinstate him "if the risk to public safety has receded."

 told the company it was wrong to impose an 

 on Trump after the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol. 

Facebook says it is setting new rules for public figures in times of civil unrest and violence, "to be applied in exceptional cases such as this." Trump has received the maximum penalty under those rules, "given the gravity of the circumstances" leading to his suspension. Because the company took his Facebook and Instagram accounts down on Jan. 7, they will remain suspended until at least Jan. 7, 2023. 

At that point, Facebook will consult experts and "evaluate external factors, including instances of violence, restrictions on peaceful assembly and other markers of civil unrest," said Nick Clegg, vice president of global affairs,  in a 

"If we determine that there is still a serious risk to public safety, we will extend the restriction for a set period of time and continue to re-evaluate until that risk has receded," Clegg said.

When Trump is allowed to return, he will be subject to "a strict set of rapidly escalating sanctions," up to a permanent ban, that will kick in if he continues to break Facebook's rules.

Facebook's decision "is an insult to the record-setting 75M people, plus many others, who voted for us," Trump said in an emailed statement, misstating the number of votes he received in the 2020 presidential election. (It was just over 74 million votes.) He also continued his baseless attacks on the legitimacy of the election.  

"They shouldn't be allowed to get away with this censoring and silencing, and ultimately, we will win. Our Country can't take this abuse anymore!" he said. 

Reversal of Facebook's long-standing approach to political speech

The new rules being applied to Trump mark a sharp break with the hands-off approach to political speech that Facebook has taken for years.

 from its policies on what speech is allowed on its platform, with CEO Mark Zuckerberg arguing that 

 is already highly scrutinized. That stance has fueled criticism from civil rights groups, Democratic lawmakers, political activists and even the company's own employees.

Now, Facebook is overhauling a key part of its approach and will no longer consider politicians' posts "newsworthy" by default. That means if politicians break the company's rules prohibiting harmful speech, they will face the same consequences as any other user. 

"We will simply apply our newsworthiness balancing test in the same way to all content, measuring whether the public interest value of the content outweighs the potential risk of harm by leaving it up," Clegg said. 

That's a reversal of how Facebook has treated politicians since 2019, when Clegg 

 the company believed political speech was "newsworthy content that should, as a general rule, be seen and heard."

However, Facebook is not eliminating the exemption entirely. It said if it decides a politician's post breaks the rules but is newsworthy, it will be left up on the site — but the company will disclose when it does so.  

The company is also leaving another controversial policy in place: it will continue to exempt politicians' posts and paid ads from fact-checking. Critics say that gives political leaders around the world a free pass to lie and whip up partisan divisions. 

Responding to Oversight Board's recommendations

The policy changes were announced Friday in response to recommendations from Facebook's Oversight Board, a panel of outside legal and human rights experts the company convened to review its most difficult content decisions. 

Last month, the board upheld Facebook's decision to suspend Trump, finding he had broken its policies against praising violence, but said the company needed to set clear rules for high-profile users. 

The board's criticisms of Facebook were scathing. It 

 the company, saying "the same rules should apply to all users of the platform." It said Facebook should act more quickly when politicians, celebrities and other people with big audiences violate its policies, because their influence can cause outsize harm. 

The board took particular aim at the "newsworthiness" exemption, put in place in 

. It said the company should do a better job of explaining the policy and when it's applied to "influential users," including politicians. 

Facebook said on Friday it has applied this policy to Trump's account once: on an August 2019 video from a rally, when Trump singled out a member of the crowd. 

In its response to the board's recommendations, Facebook said it would be more clear about how it enforces rules for all users. It's making public its system of 

 and penalties for accounts that break the rules, and explaining how it reviews posts by high-profile "public figures." 

It also laid out a new policy for how it will handle public figures' accounts "during civil unrest" — the rules it is applying to Trump. 

Because those accounts can have outsized impact, if they break the rules "in ways that incite or celebrate ongoing violent disorder or civil unrest," they face suspensions ranging from one month to two years, compared with the standard penalty of up to 30 days. 

 In addition, once they're allowed back on Facebook, these users will face "heightened penalties" including permanent bans. 

Facebook said it was "committed to fully implementing" most of the board's recommendations. 

But it did not commit to a suggestion that it conduct a review of its role in contributing to the false election fraud narrative that culminated in the events of Jan. 6, instead saying it is cooperating with law enforcement and is partnering with outside researchers to study the effect its platforms have on elections. 

 Facebook is among NPR's financial supporters.

Politics and Government News

Shannon Bond

Author

Facebook says former President Donald Trump is locked out of its platform and Instagram until at least Jan. 7, 2023. It will reinstate him only "if the risk to public safety has receded."

Trump suspended from Facebook for 2 years

Go Deeper.

Like this?

News you can use in your inbox