Arts and Culture

The blue tent folds: Big Top Chautauqua ends 40-year run in northern Wis.

Big Top Chautauqua tent
Big Top Chautauqua, a popular outdoor concert venue outside Bayfield, Wis., is closing after 40 years.
Courtesy of Big Top Chautauqua

Quick Read

Ashwabay Alliance board President Scott Griffiths cites several years of financial difficulty that led to the decision.

Big Top Chautauqua, a beloved outdoor concert venue at the base of a ski hill outside Bayfield, Wis., near the edge of Lake Superior, is closing after a 40-year run that featured shows with international recording artists including Brandi Carlile, Johnny Cash, B.B. King, Lyle Lovett, Willie Nelson, John Prine and Bonnie Raitt.

In a letter posted this week on the website of the Ashwabay Alliance, the nonprofit that manages both Big Top and the Mt. Ashwabay ski resort, board President Scott Griffiths announced that the alliance “does not have a sustainable path forward, and will not be able to produce a summer season in 2027 or beyond.”

In the letter, Griffiths cites several years of financial difficulty that led to the decision. Losses totaled $2.8 million since 2023, including a loss of about $1.1 million in the past year alone.

A band playing at Big Top Chautauqua.
Big Top Chautauqua, a popular outdoor concert venue outside Bayfield, Wis., is closing after 40 years.
Courtesy of Big Top Chautauqua

Griffiths notes a number of reasons for the bleeding of cash, including wage increases following the creation of the Ashwabay Alliance in 2022, when the two groups that separately managed the ski resort and the concert venue merged.

A major longtime donor also passed away, and the music industry saw significant changes. Artist fees and ticket prices have risen dramatically. Crowds are smaller than they were before the COVID-19 pandemic. And there’s much more competition.

“When the tent opened 40 years ago, it was one of the only places in northern Wisconsin to hear live music,” the letter continues. “Today, there is live music almost any night of the week, year-round, and the caliber of musicianship in our region rivals communities far larger than ours.”

This past year, despite a show headlined by Minnesota bluegrass favorites Trampled by Turtles that drew a record-setting crowd, ticket sales — the organization's largest revenue stream — were less than 60 percent of what was projected.

The 900-seat venue, known for its signature blue tent, was founded in 1986 by Warren Nelson and Betty Ferris.

According to an MPR News story from 1988, Nelson was commissioned by the town of Washburn, Wis., to write a musical to celebrate its centennial. The show was such a success that nearby Bayfield wanted one, too. Then local backers asked Nelson to set up shows on a regular basis. In 1986, Big Top Chautauqua was formed.

Warren Nelson
Musician Warren Nelson helped found Big Top Chautauqua after writing and producing historical musicals for the Wisconsin cities of Washburn and Bayfield. He's been creating musical shows about the people and communities around the upper Midwest since the 1970s.
MPR photo/Euan Kerr

It was inspired by the Chautauqua cultural and social adult education movement with roots in upstate New York that began in the 1970s. Early events at Big Top included lectures, theater performances and historical programs, before the focus shifted to music concerts.

“It’s a very intimate venue. It’s such a gem for the Northland,” said Vincent Osborn, a Duluth-based bassist who for the past decade has played with the Blue Canvas Orchestra, the Big Top’s house band that’s performed ever since the venue opened.

Osborn said it’s a testament to the venue — and to the broader community — that it has been able to attract such well-known musicians.

“People who can go into an arena or play in a big auditorium for 4,000 or 5,000 people, and they're happy to come up to Bayfield, Wis., in the summer with the mosquitoes and chancy weather and do a concert for 1,000 people, I think that really that's a big statement. That really shows something,” he said.

Moving forward, plans are to continue to offer outdoor recreation at Mt. Ashwabay — the one aspect of the operation the nonprofit believes is financially sustainable.

While the ski hill typically covers its own operating costs, the Ashwabay Outdoor Educational Foundation is launching a $250,000 fundraising campaign to help it make it through this winter. The Ashwabay Alliance is also looking to sell land to Bayfield County so that existing mountain bike trails can stay open.

Meanwhile there’s still hope for music to return to the Big Top at some point.

“If there is a group, a partner, or a new idea that wants to pick up where we leave off, we would love to talk with you,” the letter concludes. “We cannot promise what comes next, but we will leave the door open to new possibilities.”

Osborn, who’s also president of the local chapter of the American Federation of Musicians that represents 15 members of the Blue Canvas Orchestra, believes that Big Top can survive without the Ashwabay Alliance.

"It survived before there was a merger, and my cautiously optimistic hope is that this will be a rebirth of Big Top Chautauqua as its own entity again.”