Judge says sealed records behind search of Ilhan Omar's home could be public Monday

Go Deeper.
Create an account or log in to save stories.
Like this?
Thanks for liking this story! We have added it to a list of your favorite stories.
Quick Read
A federal judge said Tuesday that much of the sealed court record behind last month's search of U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar's Washington, D.C., home could be made public as soon as 5 p.m. Monday.
Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg said a 67-page affidavit laying out the government's evidence for the search should stay sealed for now. But he signaled most of the other records — roughly a dozen entries on the sealed docket — could be released with some redactions.
"The question is, why can't a bunch of this be unsealed now?" Boasberg said.
More than a dozen news organizations — including the Star Tribune and KARE 11 — asked the court to unseal the search warrant, the application, supporting affidavits and other records. They cited "the enormous public interest in and historic significance of a search warrant executed at the home of a sitting member of Congress," according to court filings. The New York Times and the conservative legal group Judicial Watch filed similar requests.
Turn Up Your Support
MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all.
The Justice Department argued everything should stay sealed while the investigation is active and before any decision on charges. "Unsealing everything now … imperils the investigation, and publicly exposes suspected criminal wrongdoing," the department wrote in an Oct. 27 filing.
Omar has not been charged. Top Trump administration officials have publicly accused her of immigration fraud, which she denies. She has called the investigation an attempt at intimidation. "I'm confident in the fact that I didn't do anything wrong," she told MS NOW last month.
A rare search
Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Omar's home on Oct. 12, three weeks before the 2026 midterm election. Omar easily won reelection.
According to former federal prosecutors, the move broke with a longstanding informal Justice Department practice of avoiding overt investigative steps against candidates in the roughly 60 days before an election. The Justice Department said in court filings that the attorney general approved the search and that its timing was not meant to affect the election.
Agents carried boxes of materials out of the home and seized Omar's cell phone, laptop, notebooks and passport, according to reporting by the Star Tribune.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Matthew Sharbaugh authorized the warrant, according to a court order, and placed restrictions on the search because of Omar’s role as a member of Congress, CNN reported.
Omar's attorneys have accused the Justice Department of violating those restrictions, including failing to notify Omar or the House’s top lawyer of the search and initially preventing Omar from contacting her lawyer after the search began.
The Justice Department has called the allegations false.
'A common refrain'
In court filings, the department has argued that almost nothing about the investigation should be made public, to protect the investigation and the reputations of people named in the records, including Omar. It also warned news organizations could use the records to indulge in “public scandal.”
Meanwhile, officials including the president have been open about the purpose of the investigation and have repeatedly attacked Omar personally and professionally.
In court Tuesday, the government told Boasberg the records should remain fully sealed for now because the warrant hasn’t been fully executed. It argued the warrant won’t be fully executed until agents finish reviewing some of the materials they seized.
Boasberg noted the warrant had already been returned to the magistrate judge as executed. “I don’t think I buy” that argument, he said.
He said most of the other records deal with protections for Omar’s work as a lawmaker under the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause, and he saw little in them about investigative facts, witnesses or potential charges.
Maxwell Mishkin, an attorney for the news organizations, argued the public has a particular interest in legal disputes between the executive and legislative branches.
Alessandra Serano, an associate deputy attorney general, told the judge it’s rare to release documents like these before an indictment and that a release now would offer only a partial “snapshot.” She acknowledged some legal filings could be released with heavy redactions but said details of the investigation are intertwined with the legal arguments.
Boasberg pointed out that top officials, including President Donald Trump, Vice President JD Vance and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, have already made public statements about details of the investigation. In March, Vance said Omar “definitely committed immigration fraud.” Last month, Trump wrote that Omar “has openly admitted to FRAUD” and should resign. Border czar Tom Homan has said Omar could be denaturalized and deported if fraud is proven.
“Your superiors are saying what the government is looking into,” Boasberg told Serano.
“I had zero control over what was said,” she replied.
“That seems to be a common refrain,” Boasberg said.
Omar came to the U.S. as a refugee from Somalia and became a citizen in 2000.
What's next
Boasberg ordered the government to submit all the records except the affidavit — including the docket sheet — by Friday, with proposed redactions marked. He said he'll review them himself. The news organizations can challenge the redactions by Nov. 30.
Unless a higher court halts it, the court will post redacted versions online no earlier than 5 p.m. Monday. Peter Pfaffenroth, another government lawyer on the case, said the solicitor general could consider an appeal.
Boasberg also ordered the government to tell him by Monday whether records in a separate sealed case — in which Omar is asking for her seized property back — should be handled differently.
