St. Cloud rejects new rules for data centers, moves closer to moratorium

Go Deeper.
Create an account or log in to save stories.
Like this?
Thanks for liking this story! We have added it to a list of your favorite stories.
Quick Read
The St. Cloud City Council rejected new rules for data centers after a lengthy public hearing Monday night.
Instead, the council voted 4-3 to consider a one-year moratorium on new data centers after getting more public input next month.
The policy would have changed St. Cloud’s comprehensive plan to make clear that the city is open to considering new data centers, but only in certain locations and with regulations to protect residents from negative effects.
The proposed regulations would have separated smaller data centers from hyperscale facilities — those with at least 2,000 computer servers housed in buildings larger than 10,000 square feet, or that use at least 50 megawatts of electricity.
Turn Up Your Support
MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all.
Hyperscale data centers could only be located in the city's industrial district, at least a quarter mile from residential areas, and would require a conditional use permit.
Data center developers also would have to study noise, vibration, environmental and community impacts. They would also be required to incorporate sustainability measures, including water conservation and renewable energy.
Those proposed regulations will be set aside, at least for now. Instead, the City Council plans to set a public hearing and possible vote on a moratorium for Dec. 21.
Council member Mark Johnson voted in favor of the moratorium, saying the city should take a go-slow approach.
“It's still new overall, and I do think within a year we're going to hear a lot from data centers already in existence,” Johnson said. “And if it's all worked wonderful, OK. We may not be the first ones to have one in our area, but we will know it's been proven, tested.”
Weighing the pros and cons of data centers
A crowd packed the city council chambers for the public hearing, and nearly two dozen people spoke against allowing data centers. Many raised concerns about their potential noise, water consumption and energy use, as well as the rapid rise of artificial intelligence.
Resident Susan Lau told the council that allowing data centers could harm the quality of life in St. Cloud in the future.
“What we do will impact our environment and our children and their children,” she said. “It might not still be the data center, because it might be long gone by then. But maybe we could invest in something that would be more beneficial down the road.”
St. Cloud has some smaller data centers but has not received any formal development proposals for the hypersized facilities that have generated controversy in other Minnesota communities.
But St. Cloud does have features that are attractive to large data center developers, including ample water and electricity, large tracts of land, industrial buildings and an available workforce, said Matt Glaesman, the city’s community development director.
Council member Tami Calhoun voted for the moratorium after initially supporting the policy. She said she shares some of the same concerns as residents, but supports a policy that builds in guardrails and would communicate the city’s criteria in advance.
“It says, ‘We have these very high expectations before you come in here, because we want to protect our city and we want to protect our residents,’” Calhoun said.
Some council members voted against the moratorium, citing potential benefits of data centers, including jobs and tax revenue.
Council member Dave Masters said he thinks the city “can’t be afraid of the future.”
“Technology moves very quickly,” Masters said. “By putting in these moratoriums, I feel like it is a way that we’re going to put our heads in the sand and stand back and let progress go ahead.”
