Storms start to move out of Minnesota, continue for western Wisconsin

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

(AP) - House Democrats clashed with Republicans and
the Bush administration Wednesday over whether to raise gas taxes
to pay for safer bridges in response to last month's deadly
collapse in Minneapolis.

      At a House Transportation Committee hearing, panel chairman Jim
Oberstar, D-Minn., touted his plan to pay for a bridge trust fund
with a 5-cent increase in the 18.3 cents-a-gallon federal gasoline
tax, saying Congress can't solve the problem with a "bake sale."

      But Transportation Secretary Mary Peters said a gas tax increase wasn't the solution.

      "Increasing federal taxes and spending would likely do little,
if anything, to address either the quality or performance of our
roads," she said. Instead, she called for better use of existing
funds.

      Following up on President Bush's comments last month, Peters
criticized congressional earmarks for diverting federal money from
where it was needed.

      Obertsar's bill would establish a trust fund to repair, replace
and rehabilitate structurally deficient bridges on the National
Highway System. It also would ban congressional and executive
branch earmarks. He says his proposal would raise about $25 billion
over three years.

      The Interstate 35W bridge collapse on Aug. 1 killed 13 people.

Minneapolis Mayor R.T. Rybak told committee members those deaths "were not an act of God, but a failure of man, and a failure of our inability to invest in basic core infrastructure." 

Rybak said he supports Oberstar's proposal because states and cities are far behind in providing adequate funding for transportation. 

"If you invest in quality transportation, you will get quality results," said Rybak. 

      More than 70,000 of the nation's bridges are rated
"structurally deficient" - including the bridge that collapsed in
Minneapolis. The American Society of Civil Engineers says repairing
them all would require spending at least $9.4 billion a year for 20
years.

      "It demands a national response," said Oberstar.

      The committee's top Republican, John Mica of Florida, criticized
the legislation, calling it a "knee-jerk" reaction. He instead
called for a national strategic transportation plan, to address not
just bridges but other transportation and infrastructure needs.

Gallery

Special session uncertain

911 tapes tell unfolding horror of bridge collapse

Design-build construction process has its critics

How much does it cost when a bridge goes down?

Mission complete for Navy divers

Oberstar proposes trust fund for aging bridges

Fred Frommer

Author

House Democrats clashed with Republicans and
the Bush administration Wednesday over whether to raise gas taxes to pay for safer bridges in response to last month's deadly collapse in Minneapolis.


Parties clash in Congress over response to Minn. bridge collapse

Go Deeper.

Like this?