At last, a drop in military suicides

A soldier carries flags in Arlington
A soldier carried flags to decorate graves at Arlington National Cemetery.
AFP/AFP/Getty Images

The military suicide rate has dropped this year by more than 22 percent, according to figures from the Defense Department. Despite the encouraging news, suicide among military personnel and veterans remains a perplexing topic.

The drop is the first since 2004, yet researchers don't really understand why it has happened. Compounding their confusion, half of military suicides occur among soldiers who have never deployed.

We talked with two experts to get their insight into the continuing risk and the recent improvement. Some highlights from our conversation:

Dr. Elspeth Ritchie on risk factors for suicide:
We've actually known for a while that the individual deployment history is less important than issues such as family stressors, and also the rapid operations tempo of the unit, how frequently the unit has deployed....

In active duty military, who we study very closely — we know a lot, we have a report on just about everybody who has committed suicide — the stresses are related to relationship breakup, or getting in trouble at work, or financial problems, and often there are several of these going on together. It's not usually severe mental illness, different from the civilian population. But it is a lot of stresses happening at once and, all too often, easy availability of a weapon. And kind of an impulsive suicide. It's a normal pattern.

David Rudd on the falling suicide rate among military members:
It had traditionally been about half that of the general population, but over the course of the last decade it increased to slightly above the comparable civilian population. And that's why there was so much attention paid to it ... that traditional protective variable that you had in the military context was no longer there as a result of 10 years of war. ... The operational tempo has dropped considerably in the last couple of years, with the drawdown of the activity in Iraq, and now the drawdown of activity in Afghanistan, so you see that kind of parallel drop in the rates.

Caller who identified himself as a Marine captain, deployed twice to Iraq:
In Minnesota, we have 14 percent unemployment for post-9/11 veterans. ... You don't have a job, then alcohol comes in, then depression, then relationship [and] financial stuff, and then ultimately it leads to suicide. So I think employment is a key, key component to this situation.

Ritchie on the transition after deployment:
It absolutely is a very dangerous time. People no longer have the structure of the military. They may or may not want to go to seek help. They usually don't want to go. And there can be the change in relationships and living situation. ... Anecdotally, most of the time, when we look at Guard and Reservists, it seems to be a loss of meaningful employment. Maybe they're employed, maybe they're not. ... Often, somebody has essentially been running an Afghan village, or been the mayor of an Iraqi town, and they come back and it's hard to get a job stocking shelves. So there is a real change in status, and they also miss the camaraderie. They miss their buddies.

LEARN MORE ABOUT MILITARY SUICIDES:

Deployment Factors Are Not Related to Rise in Military Suicides, Study Finds
The study, published online by The Journal of the American Medical Association, corroborates what many military medical experts have been saying for years: that the forces underlying the spike in military suicides are similar to those in the civilian world. They include mental illness, substance abuse, and financial and relationship problems. (The New York Times)

APNewsBreak: Military Suicides Drop; Unclear Why
Suicides across the military have dropped by more than 22 percent this year, defense officials said, amid an array of new programs targeting what the Defense Department calls an epidemic that took more service members' lives last year than the war in Afghanistan did during that same period. Military officials, however, were reluctant to pin the decline on the broad swath of detection and prevention efforts, acknowledging that they still don't fully understand why troops take their own lives. And since many of those who have committed suicide in recent years had never served on the warfront, officials also do not attribute the decrease to the end of the Iraq war and the drawdown in Afghanistan. (Associated Press, via ABC News)

Before you go...

MPR News is dedicated to bringing you clarity in coverage from our reporters across the state, stories that connect us, and conversations that provide perspectives when we need it most. We rely on your help to do this. Your donation has the power to keep MPR News strong and accessible to all during this crisis and beyond.