Spectacular icy tree show likely again this weekend; "Severe" to "Extreme" winter so far

Was it hoarfrost or rime ice? And what's the difference?

Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab 2
Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab on January 6, 2023.
Paul Huttner/MPR News

It’s a visually spectacular benefit of a Minnesota winter.

Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab 4
Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab on January 6, 2023.
Paul Huttner/MPR News

Parts of Minnesota awoke to a thick crystalline ice display on trees and other objects Friday morning. Hoarfrost and rime ice both produce these amazing shows.

Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab
Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab on January 6, 2023.
Paul Huttner/MPR News

But which was it at your house and what’s the difference?

Rime ice or hoarfrost
Rime ice or hoarfrost.
CBC

Hoarfrost

Create a More Connected Minnesota

MPR News is your trusted resource for the news you need. With your support, MPR News brings accessible, courageous journalism and authentic conversation to everyone - free of paywalls and barriers. Your gift makes a difference.

Hoarfrost usually occurs on clear cold calm nights. Water vapor in the air crystallizes directly onto surfaces like trees, fences, or anything that will allow attachment. This process skips the liquid phase, with water vapor (gas) turning into ice crystals (solid) on contact with surfaces.

Hoarfrost
Hoarfrost process.
CBC

Hoarfrost often has a more feathery appearance than rime ice.

Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab icicle
Hoarfrost at the Weather Lab forms on an icicle on January 6, 2023.
Paul Huttner/MPR News

Rime Ice

Rime ice occurs when super-cooled water droplets in fog freeze on contact with surfaces like trees. Rime ice goes from the liquid phase (water droplets) to the ice phase.

Rime ice
Rime ice process.
CBC

Rime ice produces heavy ice deposits that can weigh down trees and power lines. It also is very dangerous to aircraft. Here’s a great video from the Canadian Broadcast Corporation that explains hoarfrost and rime ice.

Severe to extreme winter so far

We’ve been blasted with extreme cold and copious snowfall so far this meteorological winter. (Dec-Feb)

So just how extreme has our winter been so far in Minnesota?

According to the Midwest Regional Climate Center’s Accumulated Winter Season Severity Index (AWSSI), this ranks in the top 20% of severe winters in Minnesota to date. The AWSSI calculates winter severity based on cold and snow over the season.

The Twin Cities AWSSI through January 5 is 526, which falls near the top 20% of winter severity so far.

Twin Cities winter severity index
Twin Cities winter severity index.
Midwest Regional Climate Center

The Red River Valley and Duluth are showing AWSSI reading in the extreme range. The AWSSI in Duluth is 762, into the extreme range.

Duluth winter severity index
Duluth winter severity index.
Midwest Regional Climate Center

We’re getting a break in the storm track with little snowfall for a bit, and temperatures look milder over the next couple of weeks.

But this winter is off to a vigorous start.