Auditor: Minnesota teacher licensing system 'broken'

Westview Elementary pre-K class
Lawmakers have been pressuring the Minnesota Board of Teaching to move faster on adopting new, streamlined rules for licensing teachers from out of state. Here, a student writes on the board in teacher Janet Callahan's pre-kindergarten class at Apple Valley's Westview Elementary.
Jennifer Simonson | MPR News 2015

Updated: 6:30 p.m. | Posted: 10:48 a.m.

Teacher licensing in Minnesota is "confusing," "broken" and in need of an overhaul, the Office of Legislative Auditor said Friday.

The system's problems are partly to blame for the state's teacher shortage, and the fact that the work is split between the Minnesota Board of Teaching and Minnesota Department of Education makes it difficult to hold anyone accountable for decisions, according to the auditor's report.

Create a More Connected Minnesota

MPR News is your trusted resource for the news you need. With your support, MPR News brings accessible, courageous journalism and authentic conversation to everyone - free of paywalls and barriers. Your gift makes a difference.

The Education Department also doesn't do enough to explain why it denies license applications and the teaching board's appeal process "is not consistent with the law," the report said.

Erin Doan, the teaching board's executive director, said the board agrees with the new report's findings.

"Many of the things that have been identified are things that we've identified in conversation with you in the past couple of years and have been seeking solutions," Doan said. "So we're encouraged at this point that the opportunity for those conversations is in front of us right now."

Minnesota lawmakers have been pressuring the teaching board to move faster on adopting new, streamlined rules for licensing teachers from out of state.

Legislative Auditor James Nobles is recommending teacher licensing be consolidated under one state agency. His report also notes that licensing laws change too frequently and are not clearly written.

Education Department and teaching board officials told the auditor they agree with the evaluation's major recommendations. The teaching board said it is already rewriting out-of-state licensing rules in response to a law passed last spring.

Many of the report's recommendations point to the Legislature. Lawmakers are the ones who could consolidate licensure under a single agency. And restructuring the entire licensure system as the report suggests would also be a legislative action.

Sondra Erickson, who chairs the state House Education Innovation Policy Committee, said those major changes probably won't happen this session. She wants to take her time considering the report's recommendations.

"The analysis has to, as I said earlier, be thoughtful and it has to involve some deep thinking, and that takes time," she said. "And we're moving into a campaign season when legislators think about other things than probably major changes, so I do want to go very slowly."

Erickson supports consolidating the licensing under a single agency eventually. But in the meantime, she said the Board of Teaching and the Department of Education need to finish addressing problems from many current applicants.

The board suspended an alternative form of licensing in 2012. It has since re-started that process, but is facing a lawsuit from a group of out-of-state teachers who say they were unfairly denied licenses. That lawsuit is still ongoing.