Prompts winter weather advisories as cold air moves in Friday night

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

postponement of Minnesota’s 2nd Congressional District election until February

 following the death of a third-party candidate could have unexpected consequences in the event of a disputed presidential election. 

The death of Legal Marijuana Now Party candidate Adam Weeks will force a special election next February under a 2013 Minnesota law. That law means the seat, held now by DFL incumbent Angie Craig, will stay vacant from Jan. 3 until the February special election. 

One of the ripple effects of that vacancy could be potentially massive — in an unlikely but possible political scenario that hasn’t happened in nearly 200 years. 

This scenario turns on relatively obscure provisions of the Constitution that govern what happens if no presidential candidate secures the 270 votes needed for a majority of the Electoral College. 

 to the U.S. Constitution (modifying similar provisions of Article II, Section 1), the United States House of Representatives picks the president and the Senate picks the vice president. 

But the House doesn’t just hold a vote and give the presidency to the winner. Instead, the vote is “by states.” Each state’s delegation in Congress — the new Congress, elected in November and taking the oath of office in January — decides which candidate they’ll vote for, and each state gets one vote. 

Here’s how the 12th Amendment describes the process:

Although Democrats control a majority of seats in the House, Republicans currently hold a majority of House seats in 26 states, while Democrats have a majority in 23. Pennsylvania is tied. 

The upcoming election, of course, could change that balance. 

Minnesota is one of the 23 states where Democrats control a majority of the seats. Democrats represent the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th and 7th congressional districts, while Republicans represent the 1st, 6th and 8th — a 5-3 Democratic advantage out of eight total seats. 

If all incumbent candidates on the ballot in November win, then when the new Congress gets sworn in on Jan. 3, the Minnesota delegation would have a 4-3 Democratic edge with the vacant 2nd District seat, currently held by Democratic Rep. Angie Craig. 

Those four Democratic lawmakers could then cast Minnesota’s vote for Joe Biden. 

Several congressional seats in the state, however, are hotly contested. The 

Cook Political Report rates three Minnesota districts as in play

If Fischbach beats Peterson to win the 7th, seen as the GOP’s best pickup opportunity here, and all other incumbents win, then on Jan. 3 the Minnesota congressional delegation would have a 4-3 Republican edge with the 2nd District empty — and would be able to cast Minnesota’s vote in the House for Donald Trump. 

If a majority of Minnesota’s congressional delegation couldn’t decide on a candidate to support, it would have to abstain. This would be the case if Minnesota’s delegation had four Democrats and four Republicans.

This scenario, in which the House of Representatives picked the president, has only happened twice in American history, both in the country’s early decades:

Other disputed presidential elections haven’t gone through this process. 

, for example, was settled by a decision of the U.S. Supreme Court. 

, in which several states’ results were disputed, was settled by a commission containing representatives from the House, Senate and Supreme Court, backed up by a compromise between Democratic and Republican political leaders.

History

Politics and Government News

Shows

Morning Edition

NewsPartners

Election 2020

David H. Montgomery

Author

The recent death of a third-party candidate in Minnesota’s 2nd District race will leave that seat temporarily vacant — which could end up swinging the results of the entire presidential election. Here’s how.

The death of Legal Marijuana Now Party candidate Adam Weeks will force a special election next February under a 2013 Minnesota law. That law means the seat, held now by DFL incumbent Angie Craig, will stay vacant from Jan. 3 until the February special election.

2nd District candidate Adam Weeks dies; special election needed

Members of the House of Representatives leave for Christmas break

Unlikely, but possible: How the presidency could hinge on Minnesota

Go Deeper.

Like this?