Greenest way to get rid of your Christmas tree?

Christmas is not the most environmentally friendly of holidays

Two men dressed as elves carry a Christmas tree out of an elevator.
Brothers Brandon, left, and Cameron Johnson make a delivery stop at a business in the North Loop area of downtown Minneapolis.
Courtney Perry | For MPR News 2014

Christmas is over, which means thousands of Christmas trees across Minnesota are nearing the end of their usefulness.

Many people looking for an environmentally friendly way to dispose of their tree might consider composting it or mulching it up to keep down back yard weeds.

However, the most environmentally friendly way to get rid of a Christmas tree is to drag it out to the curb and leave it for the garbage truck, according to the Minnesota Department of Agriculture.

Counties across the state have different ways of handling Christmas trees. Some pick them up curbside and may charge a fee. Others require people to drop trees off at a central location. If you’re looking to get rid of a tree, you’ll have to call your local solid waste hauler for details.

The one consistent regulation across Minnesota is where those trees end up – or don’t end up. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency planner Heidi Ringhofer said solid waste haulers are prohibited from dumping Christmas trees into landfills because they are considered yard waste. Trees are either composted at a high enough temperature to kill invasive species or burned. They’re never mixed with regular household waste, unless someone throws away their tree with the Christmas lights still attached, which is bad form.

The department of agriculture recently warned that trees and greenery brought in from eastern states might be carrying any of several damaging invasive species, including elongate hemlock scale — very small insects that feed on hemlock, fir and spruce trees. They suck out the sap and their sharp, piercing mouths damage the tree.

To keep the invasive insect from establishing itself in Minnesota, the department recommends sending Christmas trees to the landfill to be burned or buried.

In Hennepin County, environmental outreach manager Christina Schmitt suggests taking it a step further by wrapping wreaths in plastic bags before dragging them to the curb for garbage pick up.

“We don’t want these insects hitchhiking around,” she said.

Schmitt acknowledged that sending trees to the landfill might not seem like a particularly green way to wrap up the holidays, but that’s nothing new. Christmas is not the most environmentally friendly of holidays.

“You can’t recycle most wrapping papers,” she said. “That’s always a bummer for people. They think they can recycle it, but there’s metallic foil in most wrapping paper. It’s just trash.”

Then there are the strings of Christmas lights which burn out every year, and get thrown away. They’re recyclable, but people have to actually take them in to the transfer station and put them in a special bin. If string lights end up in household recycling, Schmitt says they go into the wrong machine.

“In the recycling industry, Christmas lights are known as ‘tanglers,’” she said. “They just gum up the machine. They do so much damage.”

The only environmentally friendly part of Christmas, she said, is the cardboard. That’s easily recyclable, though she said it would still be better to use a bit less of it.

“I really don’t want to be a Debbie Downer here,” she said. “I don’t want to make people feel bad. I just want us all to do better in the future.”

For everyone feeling guilty about the environmental impact of their Christmas celebration Schmitt suggested going green with new year’s resolutions.

“Resolve to bring your own mug to coffee shops,” she said. “That way you don’t throw away so many disposables.”

Or maybe resolve to buy less clothing, she said, or shop at used clothing stores.

“And it sounds old-fashioned,” she said, “but maybe try to fix your things, instead of throwing them away. Like a toaster. It might be worth fixing your toaster.”

People living in Hennepin County can get help fixing broken household items at one of the county’s monthly fix-it clinics.

And if you still feel bad about landfilling your Christmas tree, she said, buy a fake tree for next year.

“But don’t buy it new,” she said. “Buy it at the Goodwill. That way it already exists.”

Your support matters.

You make MPR News possible. Individual donations are behind the clarity in coverage from our reporters across the state, stories that connect us, and conversations that provide perspectives. Help ensure MPR remains a resource that brings Minnesotans together.