In Duluth, shoring up Superior's encroachment on Park Point
Gale Kerns has lived on Minnesota Point, the 7-mile spit of sand that juts into Lake Superior from downtown Duluth, since 1983. His house in the city’s Park Point neighborhood backs up to the long beach that lines the entire point.
Over the nearly 40 years he’s lived there, he’s seen a lot of storms.
But he never saw anything quite like what happened in October 2017, when winds over 50 mph drove huge waves relentlessly against the shore, washing away a fence and 8 feet of his yard.
"Everything was gone,” he recalled. “There was absolutely nothing left here at the end of that day.”
Create a More Connected Minnesota
MPR News is your trusted resource for the news you need. With your support, MPR News brings accessible, courageous journalism and authentic conversation to everyone - free of paywalls and barriers. Your gift makes a difference.
Kerns spent $10,000 rebuilding his yard — and the fence, which is now anchored in concrete barriers that weigh 4,000 pounds each.
Kerns’ yard has since survived several other large storms that have battered Duluth and other communities along the Great Lakes in recent years, where high winds, together with record-high lake levels, have caused tens of millions of dollars in damage.
Late last year, the residents of Park Point tried to take stock of the havoc the storms have wrought. Concerned residents formed a committee to address the erosion and high water, and surveyed their neighbors to learn how widespread the damage was. Of 95 respondents, 84 percent reported damage to their property.
"I think most of our community was surprised at how many people were affected by the water, and how many people had already spent money and taken action to do something about it,” said Hamilton Smith, who chairs the committee.
Armed with that information, the group approached the city of Duluth for help. City officials then turned to the Army Corps of Engineers. Every year, the Corps dredges sediment out of the Duluth-Superior Harbor that clogs up its 18 miles of shipping channels.
Now, that sediment is becoming a beach. Starting last month, workers have been taking barge-loads of it, mixing it with water and then piping it to the beaches of Park Point. The slurry of muddy sand is being jetted out onto the beach 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
The difference, already, is startling.
"Before this project, the shoreline was significantly closer to the residents' houses here. There's plenty of pictures that can show that,” said Monica Anderson, the Army Corps of Engineers’ project engineer in Duluth.
Now the beach stretches 50 feet out from shore, about two and a half times as wide as the eroded beach further down the shore that hasn't been replenished with new sand yet.
By the end of September, workers plan to have sprayed some 50,000 cubic yards of new sediment on a 12-block long stretch of beach, beginning just past the concrete pier that guides ships into the Duluth canal under the Aerial Lift Bridge.
That's enough sand to cover a football field about 25 feet deep.
A temporary fix
Kerns is happy with the project, which is adding beach right in front of his place. Still, he knows it's not a permanent solution. Wind and waves will continue to erode it away.
"Three to four years from now, we'll have a lot less beach than you could see here," he said.
That's because water in Lake Superior is still about a foot above normal. And climate change is expected to continue to create more big rain storms over the lakes.
But it’s also because Minnesota Point has been choked off from the supply of sand that created it in the first place.
The point was built by the natural movement of sediment, carried into Lake Superior by the rivers that feed it.
But that movement of sediment is now blocked by the two shipping canals built in the late 1800s on either end of the point, explains John Swenson, an environmental sciences professor at the University of Minnesota Duluth.
"They extend out into the lake and as such interrupt those conveyor belts of sand that are coming from the south shore and the north shore [of Lake Superior],” said Swenson. “As a result that, basically starves what we call Minnesota Point of its sand. And as a result, Minnesota Point is slowly drowning."
In some areas, Swenson said, the point is losing, on average, a meter of land a year to erosion.
Over the next several years, Swenson plans to monitor the evolution of the new extended beach, to create models of how subsequent efforts to replenish the beach might affect different parts of the Park Point spit.
Many homeowners are pushing for more frequent beach replenishment. The Army Corps of Engineers deposited dredged material at the opposite end of Park Point last summer. Before that, the federal agency hadn’t added sediment to the beach since the late 1990s.
“It’s a challenging project,” explains Corps engineer Steve Brossart.
The first priority of the engineers who maintain the waterways around Duluth is to preserve navigation. So, every year the Corps figures out the most pressing areas in the harbor to dredge. Then they test the sediment — for risks to human health, grain size, turbidity — to determine whether it can be safely reused.
Much of the sediment is too silty. What has been dredged this year, though, is about 85 percent sand, making it suitable to spray on Park Point.
But there are also additional projects competing for the sediment. This year, more than half the dredged material will be used to replenish a small island in the Duluth-Superior harbor that provides critical habitat for threatened birds.
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers wants to reuse the sediment it dredges out of the harbor because it’s running out of room to store it. The agency built a disposal facility in 1978. But it’s filling up. It only has about five years of remaining capacity.
That’s why, since 2012, Brossart said, the Corps has worked hard to find beneficial locations for the dredged material — for wildlife habitat, or, in the case of Park Point, for erosion control.
“It's definitely a win-win,” he said.
A love-hate relationship
Meanwhile, Park Point residents are taking it upon themselves to protect their homes from encroaching waters.
Dawn Buck and her husband, who live on the harbor side of the Point, spent $6,000 to raise the wooden seawall holding back the lake from their backyard. They also hauled in truckloads of dirt to raise the entire yard by a foot.
"That's the thing about Park Point,” said Buck. “You move here because you love the water. But there's this love-hate relationship. You know, too much water, too little water, water in the wrong place. That's the stress."
Next door to Buck, high lake water has flooded her neighbor’s basement. Two doors down, the rising lake nearly reached the home of another neighbor, Keith McLaughlin, three years ago.
Since then he’s purchased flood insurance, and spent $35,000 to have giant boulders hauled in by barge and placed inside the lake on the other side of his seawall.
“This will protect us from waves,” he said, looking at the costly protections in his backyard. “But when the water levels rise, this won't do anything.”
A group of Park Point residents has begun work drafting a long-term strategic plan for the point, to ensure this delicate ecosystem and important resource is resilient for the next half-century against flooding and coastal erosion.
“We either have to look at mitigation of some sort on a permanent basis,” said Gale Kerns, “or this will not be a livable place a few generations down the road.”
